Promotions πŸ’Ž Built for Sidekick ✍️ Sidekick drafts it β€” you apply it
shopify sidekick promotions discounts strategy

Choose Between Percentage-Off and Fixed-Amount-Off Discounts

Get general guidance on when a percentage discount versus a flat dollar-amount discount performs better, based on price point and margin.

Sidekick writes it β€” you put it live

Sidekick produces the content or code for this, but doesn't apply it to your store itself. You'll paste or publish the result yourself β€” the prompt tells Sidekick to explain exactly where it goes.

πŸ“‹ Prompt
Run in Sidekick
I’m deciding between a percentage-off discount and a fixed-dollar-amount-off discount for an upcoming promotion, and want general guidance before I commit to one.

Context: my average order value is around $[AVERAGE_ORDER_VALUE], my typical margin is around [MARGIN_PERCENT]%, and my target discount depth is roughly [TARGET_DISCOUNT_LEVEL] (e.g., feels like a $10-15 off or a 15-20% off kind of promotion).

Please explain, as general strategic guidance (not pulling my store’s live sales data):

  When a percentage discount tends to feel more compelling to shoppers versus when a flat dollar amount does, and why perceived value differs by price point.
  How each type behaves differently as basket size grows β€” where a percentage discount can erode margin faster on large carts versus a fixed amount staying capped.
  Common thresholds where merchants switch from fixed-amount to percentage-based offers as their catalog price range widens.
  How framing ($15 off vs. 20% off on the same $75 cart) can change conversion even when the dollar value is identical.


Keep this to general pricing-psychology guidance β€” I’ll use it to decide the format before asking Sidekick to actually build the discount code.

How to Use

  1. Copy the prompt above
  2. Open Shopify Sidekick in your Shopify admin
  3. Paste the prompt and replace the bracketed placeholders with your details
  4. Review Sidekick's response and apply the suggestions