Promotions 💎 Built for Sidekick ✍️ Sidekick drafts it — you apply it
shopify sidekick promotions discounts strategy

Decide: Discount Code vs. Automatic Discount

Get general advice on when a promotion should be a manually-entered code versus an automatic discount applied without customer input.

Sidekick writes it — you put it live

Sidekick produces the content or code for this, but doesn't apply it to your store itself. You'll paste or publish the result yourself — the prompt tells Sidekick to explain exactly where it goes.

📋 Prompt
Run in Sidekick
I’m planning a promotion and can’t decide whether it should be a discount code customers enter, or an automatic discount that applies without any code. Give me general guidance to help me choose, before I ask Sidekick to actually build it.

Context: the promotion is [PROMOTION_DESCRIPTION] (e.g., sitewide 15% off for a weekend sale, or a targeted 20% off for one email segment).

Please explain:

  When a code is the better choice — e.g., targeting one specific channel or audience (email list, influencer, affiliate) where I need to know exactly who’s using it and measure attribution.
  When an automatic discount is better — e.g., a storewide sale where I want zero friction and don’t need to track which audience segment converted.
  How the two interact with discount combination rules differently, and why mixing both types in one promotion sometimes creates confusing checkout behavior for customers.
  Tradeoffs around customers forgetting to enter a code (cart abandonment risk) versus the reduced trackability of an automatic discount.


Keep this general — no need to reference my store’s current live promotions, just help me reason through the format decision.

How to Use

  1. Copy the prompt above
  2. Open Shopify Sidekick in your Shopify admin
  3. Paste the prompt and replace the bracketed placeholders with your details
  4. Review Sidekick's response and apply the suggestions